Physician Assistant (PA) vs Doctor

Your mother or father probably wants you to become a doctor for two main reasons: it’s one of the highest paid professions in the country, and it has a tangible and positive impact on society. Those are very real benefits, but they come at a steep cost. Doctors spend over a decade in school and in training, and can rack up over a quarter million dollars in debt in the process.

The country desperately needs more medical professionals, but it simply can’t train them fast enough to meet the growing needs of an aging Baby Boomer generation. That’s why the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) predicts an average rate of growth (7 percent) for doctors but a blistering rate of growth (31 percent) for physician assistants between 2018 and 2028. But what are the real differences between these two professions?

Physician assistants perform many of the same tasks doctors do, too. They conduct physical examinations, perform and interpret medical tests, and develop treatment plans for their patients. In many cases they are dependent upon a supervising physician, but their skill set is both broad and deep enough to handle many of the needs of an aging population.

Physician assistants do not occupy a generalist role, either; PAs can specialize in nearly as many areas as medical doctors can. At the same time, physician assistants spend less time in school, spend less money on their education, and still manage to have personal relationships with their patients (and, yes, a high salary as well).

Each profession has its own separate requirements for education, licensure, continuing education, and practice authority. To get a breakdown of the small but crucial differences (and similarities) between a physician assistant and a doctor, check out our side-by-side comparison chart below.

Side-by-Side Comparison: Physician Assistant vs Doctor

Physician Assistant (PA)Doctor (MD)
EducationPhysician assistants need to earn a bachelor’s degree, followed by a master’s degree (MPAS, MHS, or MMSc) from a PA school. Medical doctors need a bachelor’s degree as well as a medical degree (MD or DO).
Timeline to PracticeIn addition to a four-year bachelor’s degree and a two-to-three year master’s degree, physician assistants need three years of healthcare experience. While it’s possible that some requirements will overlap, the general timeline to practice is seven to ten years. In addition to a four-year bachelor’s degree and a four-year medical degree, physicians need to complete an additional three to seven years of training through residencies and fellowships, making the general timeline to practice between 11 and 15 years.
Typical DutiesA physician assistant’s typical duties will vary based upon their specialization and work environment, but may include:

• Performing physical examinations
• Designing treatment plans
• Assisting in surgery
• Taking medical histories
• Ordering and interpreting medical tests
• Performing clinical research
A doctor’s typical duties will vary based upon their specialization and work environment, but may include:

• Performing physical examinations
• Designing treatment plans
• Administering medications
• Diagnosing illnesses
• Ordering and interpreting medical tests
• Addressing patient concerns
Can Prescribe Medications? Physician assistants are allowed to prescribe medications in all 50 states, but the scope of their prescriptive authority can vary from state to state and from practice to practice.

As of February 2020, a physician assistant’s prescriptive authority is determined by the supervising physician in 47 states. Furthermore, seven states place regulatory restrictions on a physician assistant’s prescriptive authority, often as it relates to Schedule II substances.
Doctors (both MDs and DOs) can prescribe medications in all 50 states and Washington DC.
Common Practice SettingsAccording to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS 2019), the three most common practice settings for physician assistants are:

• Physician offices
• Hospitals
• Outpatient care centers
According to the American Medical Association (AMA), four of the most common practice settings for doctors are:

• Private practices
• Group practices
• Hospitals or healthcare systems
• Academic institutions
Licensing and CertificationPhysician assistants need to be certified as well as state-licensed in order to practice.

Certification is achieved by passing the 300-question Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE), which is administered by the National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants (NCCPA).

Each individual state has its own eligibility requirements for physician assistants. More information can be found on the
American Academy of Physician Assistants (AAPA) website.
Doctors (both DOs and MDs) need to be licensed by a state licensing board. Requirements will vary from state to state. The Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) provides each state’s requirements for initial licensure.

• DOs must pass the Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Examination (COMLEX-USA)
• MDs must pass the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE)
• Specialty boards (for specializations) require recertification on a regular basis
Continuing Education Requirements Physician assistants will need to complete 100 hours of continuing medical education (CME) every two years in order to maintain their certification and licensure. They also need to pass the Physician Assistant National Recertification Exam (PANRE) every ten years.While the state requirements for a doctor’s Continuing Medical Education (CME) or Continuing Education and Improvement (CEI) vary based on location and specialization, they generally include:

• Earning 20 to 50 hours of CME credits every one to two years
• Renewing one’s medical license every one to three years
• Completing additional continuing education hours based on one’s specialization
Specializations Physician assistants can choose from a wide variety of specializations, which include:

• Dermatology
• Emergency Medicine
• Family Medicine
• Hospital Medicine
• Internal Medicine
• Pathology
• Pediatrics
• Obstetrics and Gynecology
• Surgery
Doctors can choose from a wide variety of specializations which include:

• Anesthesiology
• Cardiology
• Dermatology
• Emergency Medicine
• Family Medicine
• Gastroenterology
• Obstetrics and Gynecology
• Oncology
• Pediatrics
• Radiology
• Surgery
Salary According to the BLS (2019), there are an estimated 114,710 physician assistants in the US, with an average salary of $108,430 per year. To break that down further:

• The 10th percentile makes $69,120 per year
• The median (50th percentile) makes $108,610 per year
• The 90th percentile makes $151,850 per year

Do note that salary estimates will vary further based on a physician assistant’s specialization and geographical setting.
According to the BLS (2019), there are an estimated 389,180 physicians and surgeons in the US, with an average salary of $203,880 per year. To break that down further:

• The 10th percentile makes $60,280 per year
• The median (50th percentile) makes $200,890 per year
• The 90th percentile makes over $205,000 per year

Do note that the BLS doesn’t record all salary data over $205,000 per year, but many doctors, especially in the 90th percentile, make much more than this. The average wage for anesthesiologists, for example, is $267,020 per year.
Career Outlook According to BLS data, the need for physician assistants is set to grow 31 percent between 2018 and 2028, a rate that’s over quadruple the national average for all professions.

A growing and aging population requires increased care, and physician assistants are able to provide the generalist services needed in a shorter time than medical doctors.

Job prospects are particularly bright for physician assistants who are looking to practice in rural and low-income areas. And as states continue to expand the number of services physician assistants are allowed to perform, the job outlook for PAs remains extremely strong all across the country.
According to BLS data, the need for physicians and surgeons is set to grow 7 percent between 2018 and 2028, matching the average rate of growth for all professions.

The career outlook for physicians remains high, however, as graduates of domestic medical schools are almost always matched to residencies immediately after graduating.


Job prospects are particularly bright for doctors who are looking to practice in rural and low-income areas, and for doctors who specialize in treating the needs of the aging Baby Boomer generation.
Professional Associations and Resources • American Academy of Physician Assistants
• Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the Physician Assistant
• National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants
Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants
• American Medical Association
• American College of Surgeons
• American College of Physicians
• American Academy of Family Physicians
• American Osteopathic Association
• Association of American Physicians and Surgeons
• Association of American Physicians
• Federation of State Medical Boards of the United States
• National Board of Medical Examiners
• National Institutes of Health
Matt Zbrog

Matt Zbrog

Writer

Matt is a writer and researcher from Southern California. He’s been living abroad since 2016. Long spells in Eastern Europe, Southeast Asia, and Latin America have made the global mindset a core tenet of his perspective. From conceptual art in Los Angeles, to NGO work on the front lines of Eastern Ukraine, to counterculture protests in the Southern Caucasus, Matt’s writing subjects are all over the map, and so is he.

Related Articles

  • 17 December 2019

    Physician Assistants (PAs) in Kentucky: The Fight for Full Prescriptive Authority

    One solution to the shortage of physicians in Kentucky is to give PAs full prescriptive authority, which is the ability of a medical professional to prescribe patients scheduled or controlled drugs. Over the last 30 years, most states have independently updated their laws to do so, and today, PAs have the ability to independently prescribe patients with controlled drugs in 49 states. The one outlier? Kentucky.

  • 11 May 2020

    Health Careers on the Rise: The Doulas Coaching Patients through Life…and Death

    To support people and their families through what can be an emotionally difficult time, end-of-life doulas help individuals and families facilitate advanced care planning, settle logistical affairs, create legacy projects, prepare home funeral arrangements, and if requested, end-of-life doulas can be present for a dying person’s transition from life to death.

  • 5 May 2020

    Respiratory Health & Vaping: Interview with an Expert

    Replacing tobacco with vape liquid means there are numerous new substances being inhaled into the lungs, and they can be extremely detrimental to a user’s health. One major offender appears to be vitamin E acetate. A recent study in the New England Journal of Medicine found that 48 out of 51 EVALI patients had vitamin E acetate in the fluid collected from their lungs.

  • 23 March 2020

    Exercise Physiologists in Michigan: Fighting for Access to Exercise in School

    “It’s an exciting time to be an exercise physiologist because there are so many ways and places to apply this knowledge to help people,” Paulson says. “Now is the time when it serves us all to know more about exercise, not less!”

  • 13 March 2020

    Mentors in Health: Interview with a Physical Therapist Assistant

    Britany Cunningham is a licensed physical therapist assistant (also known as a PTA) who works at several clinics in Nampa and Caldwell, Idaho. As a “PRN” (short for the Latin phrase pro re nata), she has a floating schedule and works with multiple clinics as needed.

  • 2 March 2020

    Mentors in Health: An Interview with a Doula

    In response to concerning statistics about the maternal mortality rate in the United States, obstetrics and gynecology organizations are calling for increased maternal support before, during, and after childbirth. One allied health profession that serves the emotional and physical needs of expectant mothers during their birth experiences are doulas. They are professional health coaches dedicated to supporting women and their families.

  • 21 January 2020

    Issues in Chiropractic Care: The Legislative Fight for Medicare Coverage

    Since 1972, Medicare coverage has included only one chiropractic service: manual manipulation of the spine. Currently, seniors who require treatment beyond manual manipulation of the spine must either pay their chiropractor out of pocket for those services or find another provider who is allowed under Medicare to provide them.